National Police Misconduct Reporting Project

Philadelphia Officer Philip Nace


Some officers turn into bad guys themselves. They’ve lost their badges amid allegations of assault, theft, rape, fraud and drug dealing. At least 68 city cops have been charged with crimes since March 2009.

But Officer Philip Nace – the YouTube sensation who has developed an international reputation as the angriest cop in the City of Brotherly Love – is perhaps the first Philly lawman to get benched for what a police spokesman described simply as “idiotic behavior.”

Lt. John Stanford said yesterday that Nace has been pulled off the street amid an expanding Internal Affairs probe sparked by viral videos out of North Philly’s 25th District, where the 46-year-old cop patrolled with an iron fist and a foul mouth.

One of the viral videos:


National Police Misconduct NewsFeed Daily Recap 10-15-13

Here are the 15 reports of police misconduct tracked for Saturday, October 12 through Tuesday, October 15, 2013:

  • Update: Belmont, Massachusetts (Previously reported 06-20-13): A now-fired police officer was sentenced to 41 months in prison for an extortion plot that involved threatening a gambler who owed money to an acquaintance of the trooper. “The offense is a serious offense, by whomever committed it,” said the judge.
  • Bridgeport, Connecticut: A police officer was arrested on charges he assaulted his ex-girlfriend and her companion. He was off-duty at the time of the incident and has been charged with third-degree assault, threatening, and disorderly conduct. He is on paid administrative leave.
  • Oakland, California: A man claims he was illegally arrested and detained during a police department open house. He has filed a federal civil rights suit. The suit also claims the police department engaged in a cover-up as officers fabricated police reports to justify his arrest.
  • Fairbury, Nebraska: A police officer is accused of stealing a 2013 Ford Explorer. He was still wearing his uniform when he was stopped.
  • Los Angeles, California: Prosecutors have filed an assault charge against a police officer for her alleged role in an incident captured on squad-car video in which a 35-year-old mother died after a violent struggle to place her in custody. The officer is charged under color of authority for kicking the woman in the groin and the stomach during the attempted arrest, which also involved three other officers.
  • Upper Marlboro, Maryland: A deputy sheriff and a corrections officer were indicted on charges stemming from an assault of an inmate. The deputy was indicted on one count of second degree assault and two counts of misconduct in office. He allegedly struck an arrestee in the head and dragged him into an isolated search room.
  • Wayne County, North Carolina: A now-former officer is charged with four counts of obstructing justice and four counts of stealing, altering, and destroying evidence. He surrendered to SBI agents.
  • Update: Plymouth, Massachusetts (First reported 09-30-13): A state trooper has pleaded not guilty to drunken driving and other charges connected to a fatal car crash. Police say he had a blood-alcohol level more than twice the legal limit. A mother and daughter died in the crash.
  • Littleton, Colorado: A police officer charged with buying $1,300 of Ecstasy from a confidential informant has resigned from his position. He is expected to plead guilty at his hearing.
  • Fort Worth, Texas: A police officer was fired for falsifying an arrest affidavit. The chief said that though the officer reported that drugs were found on a suspect during a traffic stop, but they were actually discovered during the jail booking.
  • Richland County, South Carolina: A sheriff’s deputy has been arrested for allegedly assaulting a woman at a restaurant. Several bystanders took cell phone video; he is on unpaid suspension during the investigation.
  • Phoenix, Arizona: A police patrol officer has been arrested for alleged domestic violence. According to deputies, he punched his wife in the face, causing her forehead to bruise. He is now on paid administrative leave during the investigation.
  • Palm Bay, Florida: A police officer has been charged in a stalking case. According to police, he stalked and harassed a woman after he was given an order to leave her alone.
  • Andale, Kansas: The police chief was arrested and booked into jail for domestic violence battery. Details were not made available.
  • Marion County, Indiana: A state police officer was arrested amid allegations of sexual misconduct with a minor. The police received an anonymous compliant regarding an officer engaging in a sex act with a 14-year-old. The following investigation led to this officer’s arrest.

Paul DeJesus Harassed for Filming

From Techdirt:

Apparently, the statement from a Lancaster, PA police spokesman that citizens are allowed to film on-duty police officers hasn’t made its way to the entire staff yet. Carlos Miller at PINAC reports that Paul Dejesus, the same man who had an officer walk away from taking an accident report because he was being filmed, was again approached by a police officer who demanded he stop filming because recording his voice “violated” Pennsylvania’s wiretapping laws.

Video at the link.   The officer threatens wiretapping charges and then disorderly conduct.

Note, however, that it is the officer that creates the disturbance around the DeJesus property.

After spotting Mr. DeJesus with his smart phone, the officer could have ignored him, or walked over and said, “Good evening folks, I saw you filming and just wanted to let you know that we received a call about ______ and that’s why we are here.  To check that out.  Have a good evening.”

H/T:  Instapundit

National Police Misconduct NewsFeed Daily Recap 10-11-13

Here are the 9 reports of police misconduct tracked for Friday, October 11, 2013:

  • Update: Lawrence, Massachusetts (First reported 11-26-13): A 15-year veteran police officer was convicted in federal court of bribery and obstruction of justice for soliciting a bribe from a towing company in exchange for sending business the company’s way.
  • Greenfield, Indiana: A sheriff’s deputy was arrested after a fight with a woman he had been dating. He has been charged with residential entry, criminal mischief and intimidation.
  • Update: Crestview, Florida (First reported 03-15-12): A police major will spend the next 12 yrs in prison for racketeering. The maximum sentence he could have been given was 30 years.
  • Wyoming Borough, Pennsylvania: A police officer was suspended after being criminally charged. He allegedly hosted underage drinking parties and had a sexual relationship with a 16-year-old girl.
  • Los Angles County, CA: The family of a man shot to death by a sheriff’s deputy has been awarded $2 million by a federal jury. The jury rejected the defense that the deputy feared for his life from a man with a knife. A Sheriff’s Department spokesman said the department stands by the deputies’ action and plans to file motions challenging the verdict and may appeal if necessary.
  • Iberia Parish, Louisiana: An sheriff’s deputy seen hitting a hand-cuffed man and pushing a teen-age girl has been fired.
  • Update: Rockingham, North Carolina (First reported 11-14-13): The police chief pleaded guilty to four misdemeanor counts of larceny. He was fined $100, had a 45-day stay in jail suspended, ordered to 12 months of unsupervised probation and was required to surrender his law enforcement license.
  • Tampa, Florida: An officer was arrested and charged with two counts of welfare fraud and one count of grant theft. The chief said she was working with an inmate to use food stamp benefit cards fraudulently for mutual gain.
  • Update: Denver, Colorado (First reported 01-10-13): A police officer was sentenced to jail time, home detention and 80 hours of community service for driving under the influence and careless driving.

Houston Parking Enforcement Officer Gets the Boot

From Yahoo:

He was supposed to dole out tickets and make sure drivers were sticking to parking rules. But instead, one Houston parking enforcement agent broke the rules he was meant to enforce, getting fired this week after parking illegally in a handicapped spot and cursing at the fed-up civilian who filmed him in action.

“Like with any organization, there are some hires that work out and some that don’t,” Christopher Newport, deputy director of city parking management for Houston tells Yahoo Shine, confirming on Wednesday that the agent in question had been let go “as of yesterday morning.” And it was not his choice of parking spots that was the worst offense, Newport adds, but “his response,” which included the use of an expletive, despite knowing he was being filmed at the time. “If that’s how you make decisions, I don’t think we want you working for us,” says Newport.

Brian Moya, head of an online real estate company, filmed the unnamed parking agent pulling his city vehicle out of the spot and immediately uploaded the video to YouTube. He then called Newport’s office to log an official complaint.

Cato and Flex Your Rights are quoted later in the article.

Did NY Cops Have Arrest Quotas? Did They Lie to Meet Those Quotas?

From the New York Post:

A former city prosecutor wants the Bronx district attorney to probe a team of narcotics cops he says lied on the stand and helped put away innocent people to meet quotas.

Peter Tilem, a criminal defense lawyer and one-time ADA, has submitted an allegedly damning August deposition to Bronx DA Robert Johnson and Police Commissioner Ray Kelly from a former narcotics detective on the team.

The ex-cop, Genaro Morales, testifying in an unrelated case, admitted that he knew of cops who lied under oath when he worked in the Bronx narcotics unit from the mid-1990s to 2006.

Police officials say they plan to investigate.  Good–that’s what we want to hear.   But …wait …. did they set up arrest quotas?   Hmm.

Civilian Oversight

From the Washington Post:

Maryland Attorney General Douglas F. Gansler regularly ordered state troopers assigned to drive him to turn on the lights and sirens on the way to routine appointments, directing them to speed, run red lights and bypass traffic jams by using the shoulder, according to written accounts by the Maryland State Police.When troopers refused to activate the emergency equipment, Gansler, now a Democratic candidate for governor, often flipped the switches himself, according to the police accounts. And on occasion, he became so impatient that he insisted on driving, directing the trooper to the passenger’s seat. Gansler once ran four red lights with sirens blaring, a trooper wrote. Another account said he “brags” about driving the vehicle unaccompanied on weekends with the sirens on.“This extremely irresponsible behavior is non-stop and occurs on a daily basis,” Lt. Charles Ardolini, commander of the state police executive protection section, wrote in a December 2011 memo that said the problem had existed for five years. “Attorney General Gansler has consistently acted in a way that disregards public safety, our Troopers safety and even the law.”

Attorney General Gansler is one of the key officials that Maryland residents depend upon to oversee problems relating to police misconduct.   Hmm.

To give credit where it is due, good for the state police for not playing along with politician misconduct.

And the governor played it straight as well:

Gov. Martin O’Malley (D) was briefed, aides said, and authorized the police to take whatever corrective action they deemed necessary, including revoking Gansler’s transportation services.

Mr. O’Malley also seems to put up with traffic jams just like the rest of us.

Related item here.

National Police Misconduct NewsFeed Daily Recap 10-10-13

Here are the 7 reports of police misconduct tracked for Thursday, October 10, 2013:

  • Update: Marion, Virginia (First reported 07-17-13): A police chief has been sentenced to six years in prison for dealing methamphetamines, cocaine, and other drugs. Some of the drugs came from the police department’s evidence room. He has been fired.
  • Skokie, Illinois: A woman who was charged with driving under the influence and obstructing an officer claims in a lawsuit that a police officer used excessive force. She says that she was shoved head first into a jail cell.
  • Update: New Orleans, Louisiana (First reported 04-18-13): A now-former police officer who has been in jail since April on sexual assault charges pleaded not guilty at his arraignment. He is accused of raping a 15-year-old girl.
  • Greenville, North Carolina: The police department says a detective has been arrested on one count of violating a domestic violence protective order. He was relieved of police powers and placed on administrative duties.
  • West Columbia, South Carolina: A police officer was charged in federal court after sending explicit photos of himself to a 13-year-old girl. The police chief said that the situation is an “embarrassment” for the department.
  • Grayson County, Kentucky: A sexual assault lawsuit has been filed against the county Sheriff. He says that he has not been served the suit yet and also states, “I’m upset. I’m very offended. I’m actually shocked.”
  • Update: Chicago, Illinois (Previously reported 07-22-13): A now-former police officer who extorted protection payoffs from drug dealers at a housing project has been sentenced to 22 months in prison.

Eugene Mallory


Los Angeles Sheriff Deputies burst into Eugene Mallory’s home expecting to find a meth lab, but turns out there was no meth.

Police say that the 80-year-old Mallory, who was in bed, reached for one of his handguns.  That’s when the police shot him six times, killing him.

Mallory’s wife is now bringing a wrongful death lawsuit against the police department.

Where did the police get the idea that there might be a meth lab in this home?  According to the news account, an officer had been in the area and could smell the types of chemicals that are used to make meth.   Hmm.   Perhaps enough to conduct further investigation–watching the premises, for example.   Shouldn’t be enough for raiding someone’s home.

More here.

Cassandra Feuerstein

Another case of a woman arrested for DUI and where the controversy concerns what was done to her after she was taken to the jail.

See the video below.  An officer gets angry when Cassandra Feuerstein does not follow his instructions for the mug shot and throws her head first into the concrete bed frame.

From ABC News and the Chicago Tribune:

Creative Commons License
This work by Cato Institute is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.