National Police Misconduct Reporting Project

Controversial Police Shooting in Cleveland

13 officers fire 137 rounds and kill Timothy Russell and Malissa Williams.

Police say they fired in self-defense.

From Cleveland.com:

Russell ended up on a dead-end access road to an East Cleveland middle school, where the officers from various jurisdictions converged with the 13 Cleveland officers.

They surrounded the Malibu, and some officers were out of their cars when Russell rammed another police car, Gardner said.

Police are trained to use deadly force to stop a suspect from using a vehicle as a weapon. They opened fire.

The Cuyahoga County Medical Examiner’s Office is running gunshot-residue tests on Russell’s and Williams’ hands to determine if either fired a gun. The results should be in before week’s end.

No gun was found in Russell’s car or along the chase route. No bullet or casing was found outside the Justice Center.

Pathologists at the Medical Examiner’s Office removed 20 rounds from Russell’s body and 16 from Williams’ body. They both had additional wounds from bullets that entered and exited their bodies — Russell had 30 wounds, Williams had 20, an investigator said.

National Police Misconduct NewsFeed Daily Recap 12-1-12 to 12-3-12

Here are the 11 reports of police misconduct tracked for Saturday, December 1, to Monday, December 3, 2012:

  • New York, New York: An off-duty police officer was arrested for driving while under the influence of alcohol. http://ow.ly/fMjDT\
  • Update: Hatboro, Pennsylvania: An officer was sentenced to 15 days in jail in connection with felony charges stemming from his theft of narcotic, funds, cash and for his misuse of informants to obtain drugs to feed his habit. http://ow.ly/fM9QQ
  • Smith County, Texas: A state trooper who told authorities that he swerved to miss a deer resulting in a crash was intoxicated at the time of the accident. He has been arrested. http://ow.ly/fMhVN
  • Irvington, New Jersey: The police chief has been accused of ordering detectives in the Internal Affairs Unit to unfairly punish officers, doctor internal reports and run personal errands for him. http://ow.ly/fMl7X
  • New York, New York: A police officer, and decorated former Marine, was arrested after driving drunk and becoming involved in an accident. http://ow.ly/fMjdk
  • Freehold, New Jersey: An officer who was accused of raping an informant has been sentenced to 5 years of probation for criminal coercion and 3 years of probation for tampering with evidence. The sentencing was a result of a plea bargain. He had already forfeited his job. http://ow.ly/fMpFl
  • Eugene, Oregon: A man has filed a $3 million civil rights lawsuit against the police department and three officers for allegedly entering his home without permission and taking his mentally ill adult son to a local hospital, where he died of cardiac arrest after being “prescribed an overdose of medication.” http://ow.ly/fMs5D
  • McAlester, Oklahoma: An officer was suspended after he used a taser on a handcuffed female prisoner inside the police station. ow.ly/fM8Wa
  • Snohomish County, Washington: A sheriff’s deputy has been charged with burglary after a stove and other items were taken from a vacation property. The charges include second-degree burglary and third degree malicious mischief. ow.ly/fM3Jb
  • Peabody, Massachusetts: An officer has been charged with six counts of assault and battery on a child under the age of 14, plus a charge of disseminating obscene material to a minor. ow.ly/fJ229
  • Fort Worth, Texas: During a rash of incidents in 2010 involving Fort Worth police officers and alcohol, chief of staff Paul Henderson summed up the department’s frustrations when he declared: “We are absolutely fed up with dealing with this off-duty behavior.” He was arrested on suspicion of DWI this past weekend. http://ow.ly/fMoXb

National Police Misconduct NewsFeed Daily Recap 11-30-12

Here are the 9 reports of police misconduct tracked for Friday, November 30, 2012:

  • New Orleans, Louisiana: A police officer was arrested for allegedly stealing a gift card from an armed robbery victim’s purse. ow.ly/fJ0at
  • Camden, New Jersey: A police officer has been suspended for four days without pay after he parked his patrol car in a handicapped parking space. ow.ly/fIXe9
  • Long Beach, California: An officer was charged with 29 felony counts and 13 misdemeanor counts, including unlawful sexual intercourse, oral copulation of a person under 18, and false imprisonment by fraud or deceit. The incidents involved more than a dozen underage girls and three young women. ow.ly/fIRKD
  • Surprise, Arizona: An officer was arrested on suspicion of pointing a semi-automatic handgun at a motorist after an apparent road rage incident. ow.ly/fIxii
  • Chicago, Illinois: Another police officer has been sentenced for his part in a scheme to extort tow truck operators. He will spend 42 months in prison. ow.ly/fIlzG
  • Bennington County, Vermont:  A deputy has been charged with shooting and killing a neighbor’s dog. He has resigned from the department. ow.ly/fGWPS
  • White County, Georgia: An officer pleaded guilty to taking sexually explicit pictures of a 7-year-old girl. “The defendant violated the trust of a young girl and his community,” said a U.S. Attorney. “That the defendant committed this offense while serving as a law enforcement officer makes this crime that much more atrocious.” ow.ly/fGHSA
  • Update: New York, New York: An officer was sentenced to 15 ½ yeas in prison. He stole guns from police department lockers and sold them to drug dealers to pay for his addiction to oxycodone. ow.ly/fGpwE
  • Franklin County, Ohio: A deputy was suspended after being pulled over and arrested for allegedly driving under the influence. He tried to use his position to avoid being arrested. ow.ly/fGnns

National Police Misconduct NewsFeed Daily Recap 11-29-12

Here are the 19 reports of police misconduct tracked for Thursday, November 29, 2012:

  • Williams, Arizona: A police officer who used a chokehold on a handcuffed prisoner, and another officer who witnessed the incident, have resigned. The accused officer resigned after he was told he would be suspended; it is against police policy to put a chokehold on a handcuffed prisoner. The witnessing officer resigned after he made inconsistent statements in a separate case http://ow.ly/fECBM
  • Boulder City, Nevada: The city council voted for an independent investigation into the police chief. He has been accused of trying to destroy public records. http://ow.ly/fEDav
  • Seattle, Washington: The police have released a dash cam video showing an officer punching a suspect. The incident is still under investigation by detectives. http://ow.ly/fEDKq
  • San Juan County, New Mexico: A lawsuit has been filed against six officers alleging false arrest, unlawful search, wrongful detention, deprivation of rights and unreasonable use of force. http://ow.ly/fGkzr
  • Scottsdale, Arizona: An officer has been accused of having sex 50 times while on duty, and lying about it. He faces sanctions from the state police standards board. The day after he admitted to sex while on duty, he resigned. http://ow.ly/fGLP7
  • Oxford, Mississippi: The former head of the metro narcotics unit has been accused of “doctor shopping” for prescription medicine. He was arrested on charges alleging that he got prescriptions from at least 17 doctors. http://ow.ly/fGK7P
  • Des Moines, Washington: A couple whose dog was shot and killed is suing the police department in federal court. http://ow.ly/fGWfj
  • East Hartford, Connecticut: A woman is planning to sue the town after her 12-year-old son was allegedly struck repeatedly by an officer. “It was an experience that I don’t want any mother to experience,” she said. The boy was taken to the hospital for injuries. http://ow.ly/fGrUX
  • Update: Boulder, Colorado: A deputy has been sentenced to 18 months in prison and 20 years of intensively supervised sex offender probation.  He pleaded guilty in August to charges of sexual exploitation of a child, obscenity, and official misconduct. http://ow.ly/fGJh8
  • Chicago, Illinois: Prosecutors have announced a felony perjury charge against a now-former officer. She is accused of lying about being hit in the face with a bottle by a woman who was riding in a funeral procession. http://ow.ly/fGMUm
  • Sarasota, Florida: The police department is investigating an officer after a video surfaced of an officer allegedly slamming a homeless man’s face against a window. In a statement, the city manager said, “Sworn officers with the Sarasota Police Department have been counseled repeatedly to treat all others with respect and dignity at all times even under trying and challenging circumstances. Anything less is unacceptable and will not be tolerated.” http://ow.ly/fGT2V
  • Buckeye, Arizona: The man who was tackled and knocked unconscious after being confronted in a Walmart is suing the town and a police officer. http://ow.ly/fGleD
  • Abingdon, Virginia: An officer has been indicted by a federal grand jury on drug distribution charges. He faces up to ten years in prison and/or a fine of up to $5,000. http://ow.ly/fGSqz
  • Grand Forks, North Dakota: A police officer has been accused of holding an unloaded handgun to another man’s head during a party. He has since resigned. http://ow.ly/fGR6
  • Fairfield, Connecticut: A state trooper has been charged with larceny, and has been accused of stealing jewelry and cash from the victim of a fatal crash. ow.ly/fGTn2
  • Leola, South Dakota: The former police chief has admitted to embezzling more than $37,000 from the community’s fire department. He pleaded guilty to two counts of grand theft. Each count is a felony punishable by as much as 10 years in prison and a $20,000 fine. ow.ly/fGkbX
  • Seattle, Washington: An off-duty police officer was arrested late last night for allegedly assaulting his estranged wife. He was booked into jail for investigation of misdemeanor domestic violence assault. ow.ly/fGhqp
  • Jackson, Tennessee: The police department is investigating the alleged misconduct of a patrol officer. The investigation is centered upon an allegation of missing currency possessed by an occupant of a vehicle stopped by officers for traffic violations. ow.ly/fGg1m
  • Hillsborough, Florida: An officer is on trial; he has been charged with four counts of committing lewd and lascivious battery with a teenager. The charges are second-degree felonies. http://ow.ly/fEMv3

The Angela Jones Case: Taser and Cardiac Arrest

Video from California Highway Patrol here.

So much wrong here.  The entire encounter with the police seems dubious.  The use of the taser was unnecessary and excessive.

Some like to point out that the prisons are not filled with marijuana users.  True, but what’s hard to see are the countless injustices that go on because marijuana is illegal.  Ms. Jones was fearful of a search of her purse, which contained some marijuana.  If marijuana were legal, she would not have been concerned and this tragic incident would not have happened.

Recall that the rationale behind the criminalization of marijuana is to protect people:  keep them healthy and safe.  More and more people are recognizing that the war on drugs makes things worse, not better.

National Police Misconduct NewsFeed Daily Recap 11-28-12

Here are the 9 reports of police misconduct tracked for Wednesday, November 28, 2012:

  • Memphis, Tennessee: An officer has been arrested and charged with rape, statutory rape by an authority figure, and incest against a 16-year-old girl. At least 20 other officers in the Memphis police department have been charged in some way this year. http://ow.ly/fEpwU
  • Doylestown, Pennsylvania: An officer charged with faking his own shooting has pleaded guilty to making false reports to law enforcement. He resigned after his arrest. http://ow.ly/fEqz5
  • Des Moines, IA: A now-former officer has been sentenced to 16 years in prison for repeatedly violating probation. Most recently, he cut off his ankle monitor and police found him hiding in a clothes dryer. http://ow.ly/fEHHn
  • New York, New York: A sergeant was arrested for attacking someone. He allegedly punched the victim in the face. http://ow.ly/fEz2E
  • Fairport, New York: An officer has been accused of fabricating evidence in a personal small claims case, which has forced him to step down from testifying in court on other cases. An attorney said, “I was mortified that we would go forward and give false testimony in a case like that particularly from a person who gives testimony frequently in cases and who the public relies upon to give truthful testimony.” More than a dozen DUI cases now must be dismissed, as the officer was the key witness in them. ow.ly/fCfiB
  • Atlanta, Georgia: An officer has admitted to drinking when he drove the wrong way down a highway and struck a bus nearly head-on. He has been sentenced to 12 months probation; 10 days must be spent in jail. ow.ly/fElWY
  • Houston, Texas: A police officer has been arrested and charged in a domestic violence case. He is charged with two counts of aggravated assault with a deadly weapon. Deputies say he showed up at his estranged wife’s house under the influence, with a gun. ow.ly/fAKOh
  • Venture, California: A wrongful death lawsuit has been filed against an officer over a shooting. The suit says he violated police policy and the civil rights of a man. This is not the first time the officer has been accused of excessive force. http://ow.ly/fCaqT
  • Linden, New Jersey: A former Linden police officer admitted to filing false federal income tax returns for three years by failing to report income from the sale of rental property. He faces up to three years in jail, and penalty of up to $250,000. http://ow.ly/fCPFJ

National Police Misconduct Newsfeed Daily Recap 11-27-12

Here are the 9 reports of police misconduct tracked for Tuesday, November 27, 2012:

  • St. Lucie County, Florida: A deputy flipped over a 62-year-old handicapped woman’s car when he used a Precision Immobilization Technique to stop her car by hitting her bumper. The deputy reported that a woman driving a car seemed slumped over the wheel and she did not slow down from her “consistent 57 mph” when he turned on his blue lights. He determined that she was a flight risk. The posted speed limit was 55 mph. ow.ly/fCxKW
  • Utica, New York: A police officer was charged with driving impaired while in Niagara Falls, Canada, and is now suspended without pay. The department will not pay his attorney fees. ow.ly/fCa9q
  • Smyrna, Georgia: A veteran officer has been arrested and charged with simple assault, simple battery, and third degree cruelty to children for allowing a minor to witness family violence. ow.ly/fC5NC
  • Williamston, North Carolina: A police officer has resigned two days after he was arrested for drunk driving. His blood alcohol content was twice the legal limit when he was arrested. ow.ly/fAMa7
  • Barrington, Rhode Island: After already being charged with threatening his ex-wife, an officer has not also been charged with misdemeanor cyber-stalking and felony obstruction of the judicial system. ow.ly/fAMv6
  • Update, Coweta County, Georgia: The deputy who fired his taser at a 16-year-old as the student streaked in boxer shorts across the field at the recent football game has been suspended.
  • Oldham County, Kentucky: A deputy has resigned after an incident involving an erotic masseuse at his home. He allegedly solicited sex from her, and, when she refused, stole her cell phone. ow.ly/fAy2r
  • Charles City, Iowa: An officer has been charged with misconduct in office. The criminal complaint against him claims he failed to perform his duties when he had reason to believe a sexual assault occurred. http://ow.ly/fAvEv
  • Update: Nogales, Arizona: The police officer who had a sexual relationship with a 17-year-old girl has been sentenced to two months in jail and three years probation. He pleaded guilty to one count of sexual misconduct with a minor. ow.ly/fAArr

Another Victory for First Amendment and Recording the Police

From the Chicago Tribune:

The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear an appeal of a controversial Illinois law prohibiting people from recording police officers on the job.

By passing on the issue, the justices left in place a federal appeals court ruling that found that the state’s anti-eavesdropping law violates free-speech rights when used against people who audiotape police officers….

Illinois’ eavesdropping law is one of the harshest in the country, making audio recording of a law enforcement officer — even while on duty and in public — a felony punishable by up to 15 years in prison.

Public debate over the law had been simmering since last year. In August 2011, a Cook County jury acquitted a woman who had been charged with recording Chicago police internal affairs investigators she believed were trying to dissuade her from filing a sexual harassment complaint against a patrol officer.

The government keeps losing in court on these matters, the main problem right now is a practical one (not so much a legal one)–when cops out on the street overstep their bounds and threaten people who have their smart phones out and are recording.   If bogus charges against a citizen-journalist are dropped, the cops likely face no adverse consequences–so it continues.

National Police Misconduct NewsFeed Daily Recap 11-22-12 to 11-26-12

Here are the 13 reports of police misconduct tracked for Thursday, November 22, to Monday, November 26, 2012:

  • Middletown, Pennsylvania:  A police officer was suspended for three days for “conduct unbecoming to a police officer.” The exact reason for the suspension has not been made public. http://ow.ly/frjmd
  • Manhattan, New York: An officer was arrested for petit larceny and criminal possession of stolen property after she allegedly shoplifted from a store on Black Friday. She has been suspended without pay. http://ow.ly/fANjR
  • Belle Plaine, Minnesota: An off-duty officer was arrested on suspicion of drunken driving after a state trooper reported him driving 96 mph. The officer is now on indefinite leave. http://ow.ly/fAsdd
  • Hurst, Texas: An officer is on administrative leave after being caught on camera kneeing a teen in the back of the head while cussing at him and threatening him. http://ow.ly/fAEvr
  • Indianapolis, Indiana: A police officer has been arrested on a drunken driving charge. He failed field sobriety tests, and was speeding. http://ow.ly/fAQoD
  • Oldham County, Kentucky: A deputy has resigned from his position after an incident involving a masseuse at his home. According to the police report, he solicited sex from the masseuse and, when she denied him, he stole her cell phone. http://ow.ly/fAy2r
  • Philadelphia, Pennsylvania: Officials are investigating whether police officers used excessive force while arresting a man. The officers were caught on camera beating him with a baton. ow.ly/fAd0w
  • San Francisco, California: A deputy sheriff is facing misdemeanor charges stemming from an off-duty incident when she, accompanied by two friends, allegedly forced her way into a man’s house, brandished a pistol, and threatened him. She has been assigned to administrative duties pending the investigation. ow.ly/fAdPv
  • Memphis, Tennessee: An off-duty Memphis officer has been arrested on charges of driving under the influence and reckless driving. He has been suspended with pay while the incident is investigated. ow.ly/fAbLR
  • Broward County, Florida: A deputy who was arrested after a prostitution sting was sentenced to 6 months of probation. He has also been fired, but is seeking to re-join the agency. ow.ly/fAaIJ
  • Bledsoe County, Tennessee: The sheriff was arrested for disorderly conduct following an incident outside of a restaurant. He was allegedly involved in a fight with several other men and women. ow.ly/fzUpe
  • Clarksville, Tennessee: An officer shot a dog that was on a chain, and clearly within it’s property, in the head. http://ow.ly/fs2J1
  • Update: King County, Washington: A family has reached a $1.478 million settlement with the county. An officer assaulted a man, and the department covered up the evidence. The judge said, “Defendant King County’s lack of effort and pattern of deliberate indifference with respect to producing responsive information to Plaintiff Harris is reprehensible. This reckless indifference in its failure to produce these three documents – documents that were indisputably relevant – is the functional equivalent of intentional misconduct.” ow.ly/fAoEh

National Police Misconduct Newsfeed Daily Recap 11-20-12 to 11-21-12

*Note* This is the recap for both Tuesday and and Wednesday as I was out of the office Wednesday.

Here are the 23 reports of police misconduct tracked for Tuesday, November 20 to Wednesday, November 21, 2012:

  • Newark, New Jersey: The ACLU says police have reached a settlement with a teenager who was handcuffed and detained for phone video. The teen says police illegally seized her phone and deleted a video from it. http://ow.ly/frucK
  • Asheville, North Carolina: An officer has been charged with misdemeanor child abuse after investigators found bruises on a child after a spanking. The arrest warrant states that the officer is not the child’s father. http://ow.ly/fpBLU
  • Glasgow, Kentucky: The sheriff who is facing federal civil rights violations has been indicted on additional counts of excessive force and falsifying documents. He is facing 13 counts; his term as sheriff ends in December. http://ow.ly/fpCJG
  • Washington Township, New Jersey: An officer is facing charges of committing official misconduct, submitting a false report to law enforcement, harassment and tampering with public records. “At some point the decision will be made to see if he stays on [the force,]” said the police captain. He also said that the officer was required to turn in his badge, all police equipment and is not to identify himself as a law enforcement officer. http://ow.ly/fpXls
  • Lee County, Florida: After an internal investigation revealed that he stole merchandise from a Publix store while in uniform, an officer was fired. He then lied about stealing the items because “I was afraid of being labeled a thief.” http://ow.ly/fpJlT
  • Eastpointe, Michigan: A detective has been charged in the theft and exchanging of tires, slot machines, watches, and other items from a police forfeiture shed for drugs and money. He was a 14 year veteran, and resigned during the investigation. http://ow.ly/fpTQF
  • Greeley, Colorado: A police officer has been charged with a class four felony theft for allegedly falsifying his time sheets. http://ow.ly/fpWyk
  • Broward County, Florida: An officer is again accused of falsifying official documents. He faces a felony count of official misconduct, a misdemeanor count of falsifying public records, and two counts of petty theft. The charges are punishable by up to 6 years behind bars. “We do our best to weed out people that we don’t think are worthy of wearing a badge and being in law enforcement,” said the Sheriff. “Those that betray the public trust shouldn’t be working here. This isn’t the first, of numerous times, where internally we’ve done our job to weed those people out only to have them return due to binding arbitration and the ruling of an arbitrator.” http://ow.ly/fpX0d
  • McLeod County, Minnesota: A deputy has been indicted by a grand jury in relation to a shooting incident. He was placed on paid administrative leave pending the outcome of the criminal proceedings. http://ow.ly/fpFtP
  • Piedmont, Oklahoma: An officer who wrote a $2,500 ticket to a mother on a public urination complaint against her three-year-old son has been fired. http://ow.ly/fs2VX
  • New Orleans, Louisiana: An officer has been charged with federal tax evasion. He didn’t file tax returns for three years, and, in all, he took $68,000 from the federal government. http://ow.ly/fs3s
  • Huntsville, Alabama: The city council has agreed to pay $22,500 to a victim of excessive force. The man was beaten after being taken into custody. The officer involved in the beating lost his job after the incident. http://ow.ly/fs3It
  • Uvalde County, Texas: A police officer was arrested for allegedly possessing and promoting child pornography. He was immediately fired after the arrest. ow.ly/fs4yg
  • Update: Pocahontas County, West Virginia: More claims have been filed against a deputy saying that he used his position to exert influence over a woman for sex. http://ow.ly/frriA
  • Saratoga Springs, New York: A city police officer has been charged with misdemeanor 3rd degree assault. The charges stem from a bar fight. The officer, has been suspended without pay since the incident, along with two other officers. http://ow.ly/frikp
  • Rock Hill, South Carolina: An officer was arrested on charges of driving under the influence. He failed field sobriety tests, and is now on procedural suspension. http://ow.ly/fq00v
  • Rogers City, Michigan: A former officer pleaded guilty to three misdemeanors resulting from an investigation into his activities during his time in the department. He pleaded guilty to carrying a loaded weapon in a vehicle, interfering with a crime report and willful neglect of duty by a public officer. http://ow.ly/frdJA
  • Martinsville, Virginia: The second in command at the sheriff’s office is on leave after being charged with a DWI. She is on administrative leave and disciplinary sanctions are being taken. http://ow.ly/frei1
  • Chicago, Illinois: An officer was fired for working as a bouncer at a nightclub, and participating in a “lube wrestling event,” while on convalescent-duty status. http://ow.ly/frfsn
  • New Haven, Connecticut: A Yale University football player is suing the police, saying that he was seriously injured when they used a taser on him during a nightclub raid. The police chief said that an assistant chief, who is now retired, was supervising the operation and lost control of the inspection.  “It was poor planning, poor decision making and poor leadership,” he said. “I take full responsibility and the department learned some valuable lessons.” ow.ly/fs47h
  • Jacksonville, Florida: A detective has resigned after making threats directed toward the president. The secret service is now investigating the incident. ow.ly/fs3Wo
  • District Heights, Maryland: The FBI raided a family’s home and shot at an 18-year-old girl. No one in the home had a gun. The FBI has only said that agents from the Baltimore field office were there exercising a search warrant and shots were fired. Neighbors in the quiet neighborhood heard the gunfire and were stunned. There have never been any problems at the home. http://ow.ly/frqep
  • Pascagoula, Tennessee: A grand jury has indicted the commander of the Narcotics Task Force on a charge of misdemeanor simple assault. The charge comes from a shooting. “The shooting at the task force office was disappointing. As law enforcement officers, we are held to a higher standard. The laws should apply to us as well as anybody else in the community. We should all be held accountable for out actions,” said the police chief. http://ow.ly/fq291

Creative Commons License
This work by Cato Institute is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.